GUSH: More Than Double The Pain (NYSEARCA:GUSH)

The energy sector has recently been under pressure since the European crisis, shortly followed by the Ukraine-Russia war which pushes oil prices to extreme volatility. For anyone seeking for more volatility in an already highly volatile sector, Direxion Daily S&P Oil & Gas Exp. & Prod. Bull 2X Shares ETF (NYSEARCA:GUSH) may just be what you’re looking for. Just before that, this article is what you need to walk through some of the key quantitative risks you may not be aware of.

GUSH is a leveraged ETF aiming to seek 2x the daily performance of S&P Oil & Gas Exploration & Production Select Industry Index. There are already 2 major caveats just with the fund objective alone. Firstly, 2x daily performance is not at all equivalent to 2x returns over the long-term (even just beyond 1 day horizon) due to the compounding effects. You may read more from the Seeking Alpha’s introduction to Leveraged ETF to understand the dynamics better. Secondly, GUSH actually does not fully replicate the index as it has certain minimum market cap ($300-$500 million) & liquidity ratio criteria, and all invested companies are only US-based. This means that the ETF would exclude smaller cap companies or companies with insufficient liquidity ratio, even though the index is dominated by large cap names with a median market cap of $4.3 billion.

As of Q1 2023, the fund holds a large proportion of Treasuries for liquidity purpose when trading derivatives to achieve leveraged outcome, while some of its top holdings seem misaligned with the index top holdings. The fund may be achieving exposure on some companies through derivatives.

Performance & Risk Analysis

Since 2021, GUSH has outperformed all of its peers including the XOP which tracks the underlying index for GUSH. The 150% cumulative return was mostly driven by the energy rally in 2022, making the returns of S&P 500 (SPY) negligible throughout this period.

However, if you’ve bought the ETF since pre-Covid, you would have lost almost all of your money when oil prices sank during April 2020 to record low levels. The chart below clearly illustrates the main disadvantage of GUSH as large losses cannot be simply offset with returns in the future due to the outsized effect in losing capital base. As a comparison, the XOP which dropped more than 50% by April 2020 has now recovered to be gaining ~30%.

Another bombshell to drop: GUSH has an overwhelming ~80% annualized volatility which is about twice as much as XOP and more than 4 times of SPY. Looking at the Bollinger Bands chart, the fund has frequently exceeded its standard deviation, demonstrating the high volatility in play.

With such a high volatility, the fund is almost guaranteed to underperform even just the index itself (without leverage) unless significant return is achieved (>60%, which was what happened during 2022).

For instance, if the Index’s annualized volatility is 100%, the Fund would be expected to lose 63.2% of its value, even if the cumulative Index return for the year was 0%.” – Extracted from the Fund’s Prospectus

On the other hand, the fund has mostly been doing what it is supposed to do with rolling Beta (to XOP) closely navigating around 2 since 2021 – which basically means GUSH moves by 2 whenever XOP moves by 1, hence achieving the 2x leverage effect.

The tight correlation between GUSH and XOP (staying very close to 1) also indicates the close proximity and ability of the ETF to effectively track exposure of its underlying index.

Besides, there have been several occasions where rolling Alpha levels fluctuate significantly, while it has been mostly negative since the start of 2023.

Fundamental Deep Dives

Looking across the fundamentals of top holdings within GUSH, they are mostly trading at cheap valuations with PE ratio ranging between 2.3x and 20.4x, with PB ratio as low as 0.8x. For context, S&P 500 is currently trading at around 22x P/E, while XOP trades lower at 4x P/E and XLE at 7.2x.

With most of these companies being energy producers which benefited hugely from the energy rally last year, the profitability metrics look phenomenal with return on equity as high as 86.5%. This is expected to come down to average levels as the energy market cools down with revenues estimated to drop.

Even though most of its top holdings have relatively low levels of debt, their quick ratios are often below 1 (meaning current assets + inventory is lower than current liabilities). This may be perceived as unhealthy although it is quite a norm for the oil & gas industry.

Conclusion

Similar to other leveraged ETF, GUSH is not designed to be held for long-term investment due to the extreme levels of volatility and high vulnerability towards downside risk. However, the fund does maintain a good 2x exposure with close proximity to the underlying index for any investor seeking for such opportunity.